Earlier this month, Whiting Petroleum (NYSE: WLL) declared bankruptcy, becoming the first high-profile E&P casualty in the Coronavirus downturn. While it’s unclear how exactly the Chapter 11 process will turn out, we’ve taken the opportunity to dig through their inventory looking for potential bargains. We calculated breakeven prices for their four big remaining acreage chunks, and while almost all the open acreage fails to breakeven at $60/bbl, the inventory along the river offers decent returns at $55-60 for operators willing to brave the complex surface issues.
IN THIS POST:
Stack Ranking Whiting’s Remaining Acreage with Novi’s ML Model
Two weeks before the bankruptcy announcement, we posted that the Bakken Core was running out. Whiting is certainly not exempt from that conclusion, having drilled up much of their core Sanish/Parshall acreage (they also divested some excellent acreage to RimRock, more on that in a coming post).
The North Dakota Industrial Commission (NDIC) provides one of the best state-level datasets, and Novi has built a model covering the entirety of the (North Dakota) Williston. We used Novi Prediction Engine to analyze their acreage and generate economics, in the same way our Customers use our software to perform this type of analysis. The following video walks you through how we built these predictions:
We analyzed four type curve areas across Whiting’s acreage. We mostly followed Whiting’s Type Curve area nomenclature, but split areas where needed. As an example, we broke out Eastern Hidden Bench broken out from Western Hidden Bench.
Across the four areas, the Novi Model shows that the best acreage is located in the Parshall Infill and East Hidden Bench areas. Next, we’ll go into more detail about the predictions and economics.
Type Curves and Breakevens
Parshall Infill and East Hidden Bench show the highest predictions, by far, outpacing the East Missouri Breaks & Northern acreage by 50-80,000 bbl over the first two years. To turn this into economics, we used Whiting’s 2020 cost guidance (contact us for more details). We ran predictions at three price decks: $40/$2.00/$12, $50/$3.00/$15, $60/$3.50/$18 (price per bbl oil/mcf/bbl ngl).
Parshall Infill wells perform the best, showing a (30% IRR) breakeven at $50/bbl, with East Hidden Bench wells breaking even at a ~$55 strip. Neither the Northern wells nor the Missouri Breaks wells break 30%, even at $60/bbl.
A Bit More on ‘Hidden Bench’
The Parshall/Sanish infill opportunity fits neatly into the legacy field playbook — buy a developed field with declining production, drill some infill wells, keep costs down. Of the “new drill” opportunities, the East Hidden Bench / East Polar area has the highest returns–but the inventory has likely slid down Whiting’s priority due to tough surface conditions: a lake surrounded with rugged topography, state parks, and national forest.
This area also differs from the other Whiting acreage in being deeper and gassier. This could make for operational headaches — or if you have a bullish case on regional gas pricing, it could be a benefit to a buyer.
With per-well NPVs $1-2MM better than Missouri Breaks or the Northern acreage, the Hidden Bench wells will still be more economic even with higher pad construction costs. Given that PUDs are going for $0 in today’s market, the exposure to execution risk is minimal, and the upside is some of the last remaining Tier 1 acreage in the basin.
The Last Mile: Completions Optimization
We ran predictions at four different completions designs: 500#/ft, 700#/ft, 900#/ft, and 1100#/ft, all with a 1 ppg ratio and 220′ stage spacing. The different areas show different responsiveness to completions intensity, with Parshall Infill seeing the greatest response.
As the completion uplift varies around the basin, so do returns with respect to completions designs. At $60/bbl, our model shows best returns at 1100#/ft for the Parshall Infill and North Nesson/North Polar areas. East Hidden Bench prefers the smallest design, perhaps because the higher lighter fluids require a less-intense stimulation.
Whiting, in recent years, has dropped their average proppant loading from 1100 to 700 #/ft. These results suggest it may have been a mistake to do so across the board, and a tailored approach offers improved returns. With sand prices likely to fall commensurately with frac activity, operators may be able boost production by 20-30% at an assumed lower materials cost. Although we did not model this reduced materials cost case, we easily could have.
- Whiting has a wide range of acreage quality, with some offering decent to good returns at $50/bbl:
- The East Hidden Bench / East Polar development area around the lake offers by far the best newdrill opportunities, with breakevens just above $50/bbl. Surface issues (including rugged topography and parks) make development difficult, however.
- Parshall Infill wells have even stronger returns, with an average NPV of $2.49MM at $50/bbl.
- Whiting could improve returns by tailored completions: increasing proppant loading in the Parshall and Northern acreage and decreasing it in Hidden Bench and Missouri Breaks.