Benchmarking the Haynesville with Novi Insights
Want to understand what's driving performance in the Haynesville? In this product video, Hollee Baird, Data & Analytics Technical Advisor at Novi Labs, demonstrates how to use Novi Insights to benchmark operators across the Haynesville. Explore production trends, completion strategies, EUR performance, formation development, and recent industry consolidation, all through interactive rankings, maps, and production analysis.
- Hollee Baird
- Video Duration: 21:46
Novi Insights Product Video Description
The Haynesville is one of North America’s most important natural gas plays, but how do today’s leading operators really compare?
In this product video, Hollee Baird, Data & Analytics Technical Advisor at Novi Labs, demonstrates how to use Novi Insights to benchmark operator performance across the Haynesville. Using interactive rankings, production analysis, and mapping tools, she explores production trends, completion strategies, normalized EUR performance, formation development, and recent industry consolidation to uncover what drives success in the basin.
Whether you’re evaluating operator performance, analyzing completion design, or researching one of the industry’s most active gas plays, this walkthrough shows how Novi Insights helps you turn complex data into actionable insights.
Hi, everyone. Thanks for stopping by. I'm Holly Baird. I'm a data and analytics technical adviser here at Novi Labs. And today, I'm gonna be talking about the Haynesville, which is probably the most interesting story in US gas today. So I'm gonna spend a few minutes giving you some context about the Haynesville and then get into the Innovi Insights platform and show you the data live. So quick orientation first, and I have some slides. The Haynesville sits in Northwest Louisiana and Northeast Texas with the core of the basin in DeSoto, Caddo, and Bossier Parishes in Louisiana and extending into Panola and Harrison County in Texas. It's a very deep play. Wells run ten thousand to eighteen thousand feet, which makes it expensive to drill But yields very high quality dry gas. And this map from here from the EIA shows the extent. It's older. It's from two thousand eleven, but the red outline is showing the extent of the Haynesville, and the blue is the Bossier. So here's the arc of the play. It is it was first commercially developed in two thousand eight, and ramped aggressively between two thousand eight and two thousand fourteen during the shale boom. In two thousand sixteen, gas prices crashed. Henry Hub fell to a dollar and fifty cent per MMBTO, and that was the lowest in roughly two decades. Rigs left, production dipped. And what pulled it back out was in two thousand seventeen, the modern shale boom. So there was a step change in completions, drilling much longer laterals with bigger fracs that reset the well of economics and restarted growth. Production climbed from there to a peak near seventeen BCF in two thousand twenty three and then pulled back in twenty twenty four when Henry Hub prices fell again. Fell below three dollars and fifty cents, which was the is kind of the benchmark that most operators need to drill profitably. In the last year, it started ramping up again on LNG demand, and that whole story is gonna be available in the data we're about to look at. So a little bit of geology because that's my background. The Haynesville is a stack play, which makes it especially attractive. So the primary target is the Haynesville shale. It's a major producing formation in the area. The Bossier sits directly above it, and the two are becoming increasingly developed together on the same pad. And codeveloping the Bossier will add inventory depth without having to buy new acreage, which is super attractive. Below those formations is a smack over, which is the source rock that charged the whole system. Above the Bossier and the, Haynesville is the Cotton Valley Sands, which are an older conventional target. And sack pay means more wells per section and more drill years of drilling from a position an art an operator already has. So fresh story, within this basin is the a shift into who owns the play. So in the last couple years, Japanese companies have put about nine billion dollars into Haynesville through two separate deals. So Mitsubishi Mitsubishi acquired Aethon Energy in January of twenty twenty six for about seven point five billion and rebranded it to Atomos Energy. And because Mitsubishi already holds Cameron LNG capacity, that production is tied straight to its own export offtake. A few months earlier, JERA, Japan's largest power generator, bought into the Western Hanzville for about one point five billion. So two Japanese majors, three months apart, both buying gas as an LNG feedstock. And that's really the thread that's tying all this together. So the Haynesville sits closest to the Gulf Coast LNG complex. That's around fourteen point five BCF per day of existing export capacity with Sabine Pass in Cameron, the nearest terminals here in Louisiana. And as US LNG export capacity grows, having gas supplied directly to that infrastructure is enormously valuable, which is exactly why the Japanese capital is showing up here and not somewhere else. And so that's the backdrop. Now let's get into the platform. Enough with these PowerPoint slides. So I'm in Novi Insights already, and I can turn on a little shapefile of the basin showing the extent of the Haynesville Shale. I'm filtered down to the Haynesville Basin. So that's what filter is already on the map. And as you can see, I've got a lot of wells, over a hundred thousand. So let's narrow that number down further and drop out the verticals. I'll turn on my horizontal wells right here, hit apply, and watch the well count. It's gonna drop down to around twelve thousand wells. That's a big drop. And the vast, that's because the vast majority of the wells in the area are vertical. So Cotton Valley and Travis Peak can which are, conventional plays and that those vertical wells targeting those formations go back decades. By filtering to the horizontals, we're isolating to the modern shale program. So I'm also in the ranking tab, which we're gonna use a lot today. It's a leaderboard. So whatever metric I pick, nobody's gonna rank every operator, formation, or county, whatever you're choosing to look at, and that's represented by my filter set of wells here. And it's gonna rank them against each other. So right now, I'm on a bar chart, and it's grouped by current operator. And the metric that it's on right now is total gas reduction in MCF since this is a gas play. As you can see, expand energy is so far ahead, its bar barely fits on the screen. Expand is the result of the Chesapeake Southwestern merger, and that bar is reflecting decades of cumulative production from the largest acreage position in the basin. I can click on that bar, and I can see where those expand wells are. Pretty big play, primarily in Louisiana in the heart of the basin in DeSoto, Red River, Caddo, and a little bit of Northern Sabine. Adam Moss is in second, so that's again the Mitsubishi rebranded entity we just talked about. Six months ago, you would have sent Ethan in that spot. And one nice thing here is I can toggle between current operator and original operator. And switching to original operator, Chesapeake is now at the top with Southwestern kind of down towards the second third of the grouping. Aethon is number two, so that has now become Adamas. And this toggle is really useful anytime you wanna see a position before transactions happen. I'm gonna switch back to current operator. And let me show you these metric drop downs because this is where a lot of flexibility lives. So on the production side, I can look at *** *** gas like I have on now. I can look at average daily gas. I can switch that to oil or flared gas. And on the completion side, I can rank by lateral length, proppant for lateral foot, fluid, or proppant to fluid ratio. Lots of options. So this rankings view is a production leaderboard or a completion completion design benchmark just by changing one of to one of these drop downs. So let me walk through a few metrics and see what the trends say. So I'm gonna look at, average lateral length, to see, and I am going to also turn this filter on to wells that we have drilled on or after two thousand fifteen because we wanna look at the modern program. That'll strip out the earlier vintages, that are shorter, have a little less aggressive completion design. So I'll hit apply. And now I'm gonna see these average lateral lengths for wells drilled after two thousand fifteen in the Haynesville. And you can see there's a tier of operators that average lateral length is pushing past eight thousand feet. That's well over a mile and a half. Trinity operating sits at the top with wells averaging almost ten thousand feet. I can also switch to total lateral length to see who has most feet of horizontal wells in the ground, and, clearly, that's gonna be expand energy. So they have over almost six hundred million feet of lateral in the ground. I am going to switch over to average profit per lateral foot to look at completion design, how much sand operators are packing into each foot. And Apex is up around four thousand feet per foot, which is very high intensity. Let's see where they're located. They've got a hundred and fifty seven wells. Looks like they have a lot in Caddo and kind of on this Texas, Louisiana border. Adam Moss is second, so they're also running a pretty intense completion design program over there. Meanwhile, we can look for expand kind of in the middle of the pack at three thousand pounds per barrel pounds per foot. And then Exxon BP, a little less intense. We'll keep an eye on BP because that will come back later. And the metric I wanna really wanna land on is EUR. So that's estimated ultimate recovery. So not only can I look at actuals, I can look at forecasted values in this view? I'll go to average thirty EUR gas, and that's gonna be measured in MCF. So before I look into that too much, I'm gonna raise the minimum well count to twenty five. And by default, this will include any operator with at least twenty ten wells, but an average can be badly skewed by a small sample. So one or two great wall wells can put a tiny operator on top without telling you anything repeatable. Setting the floor to twenty five will keep keeps the leaderboard to operators running a real repeatable program. Now let me normalize. I'm seeing you are total EUR, but let's normalize by laterally. So I'm going to be looking at expected recovery per foot of lateral instead of well, per well. This is the cleanest read on rock quality and completions efficiency. It takes advantage of simply drilling a longer lateral out of the comparison. So the order has changed. So BP moves to the top. So we saw earlier they weren't running an aggressive completion design program, but then Apex is number two who was running at four thousand pounds per foot. I'll click on VP to see where they sit. I can see that they have two hundred nineteen wells, and they're kind of in this corner between Bossier and Caddo Parishes, as well as in the Texas side, which is interesting in this little peninsula of wells in the in the Haynesville in on the Texas side. So BP isn't necessarily drilling the most wells or the longest laterals, but foot for foot, their wells are expected to recover the most gas, which points straight to a rock quality and, perhaps completion designs in the area. And it's worth saying where these EUR numbers come from because people always ask. So they're not simple decline curve fits. NOVI generates them on an autoregressive machine learning forecast. So the model learns from the full producing history of every well in this basin, projects each each well forward, and we aggregate those well level forecasts at the operator level right now. So this is a data driven forecast across the entire well population, not a hand picked type curve. So let's switch back to total gas because I'm gonna start to look at trends over time. And we're also gonna turn off our first production year filter. I want the full history and view for the next thing we'll look at. And I'm going to switch over to the line chart and change the grouping to formation. So now instead of looking in the leaderboard, we're going to be look at looking at how each formation's production has grown over time. So the Haynesville Shale dominates completely, and that's that orange line, which is expected. But look at the Bossier in blue starting to creep up, both the Bossier Shale, which is what they call the portion of the shale above the middle Bossier but below the upper Bossier, as well as this middle Bossier is also creeping up. Bossier contribution has been growing, especially in recent years, as you can see. Bossier sits directly above the Haynesville, as we discussed before. And as the core of the Haynesville acreage is tightened and operators have gained experience, co developing the Bossier from the same pad has become more attractive. Adds inventory depth without having to add more acreage. The chart also tells the price story, and there are two dips worth pointing out. So you can see this first major one in two thousand sixteen. That was when the gas price crashed. So Henry Hub went to a dollar fifty. The gas directed operators slammed the brakes. Rigs left the Haynesville. Completions paused, and you can see production begin to creep right back up. And what pulled it back out was the modern restart. So longer laterals, bigger completions, more efficient, drilling and completions programs that made wells economic again. And there, the production climbs all the way up to this tip top peak in twenty twenty three. So that's when production hit nearly seventeen Bcf per day. Operators were ramping really hard while prices supported it. Then twenty twenty four, you can see that dip right here. Why don't we change the scale? We can drill in. So you can see that dip in twenty twenty four when prices fell below breakeven. And then most recent months, you can start to see instead of yearly, because we don't have all of twenty twenty six reported, I can go to monthly. You can see the start of a new ramp as LNG demand pulls volume forward. So I'm gonna scale it up. Notice these recent months aren't completed yet. We're still waiting on state data to populate our most recent months, but you can see the dip in twenty twenty four and then production start to ramp back up. So we'll see what happens as we get more data from the state of Louisiana. Okay. And the state of Texas as well. Don't wanna leave them out. So let me switch to the pie chart view now, and I'm gonna group by county and parish. And we're gonna start to look at market share by geography. And we're also going to look at some of the geology and how that geography, that market share by geography is shaped by the geology. So I'm gonna switch to county. And you can see that production the production market share is dominated by DeSoto County sorry, DeSoto Parish in Louisiana, followed by Red River, and then closely behind by Caddo and then Panola to a smaller degree Harrison, and then we have this long trail of smaller producing counties. So there's around twenty five counties and parishes in this play, which tells you how wide this basin is, but the production is clearly anchored in the northwest Louisiana core. And the natural question is why those few counties own so much of the pie, and the answer is geology. So to show that, let me filter just to the Haynesville formation in my filter tray. Hit apply. It's a dominant contributor, which is why we're gonna look at it. And I'm can color my map. I have it on true vertical depth, and the those court counties sit in this geologic sweet spot of around eleven to thirteen thousand feet. I can click on a county to kind of highlight its individual depth. So here's DeSoto right here. So it's deep enough to put the rock in the dry gas window with full thermo thermal maturity. It's hot, three hundred or three hundred fifty degrees and over pressured, but it's not so deep that it stops being economic and that all the hydrocarbons are cooked out of it. And the high pressures here are what drives high initial rates and the big u EURs we just saw BP posting. I can switch to depth to see how sorry. I can switch to thickness to see how thickness changes by county with geographically. And I can see it gets real thick as you move over to the east in Red River. And, again, DeSoto's kind of in the sweet spot. The formation seems to be better in thicker areas. So in DeSoto, Red River, to a lesser degree in Caddo. So all of these different counties are have good rock for different reasons. So it has to be in a sweet spot between TOC, brittleness, thermal maturity, pressure gradient, that make these this core good rock, which is why the production share of activity and the best URs are all concentrating here. So now let me clear the Haynesville formation filter, and we'll get back to the full picture and switch the grouping from county to current operator. This is that consolidation story in one image. So expand synergy slice is enormous. Adamas is second, and Comstock is close behind in third. After those, the pie starts fragmenting into a long tail of smaller operators, royalty backed positions, and private equity names. The top right operators here are all the product of major deals. So expand from the Chesapeake Southwestern merger, Adam Moss from Mitsubishi's Aethon acquisition, and Comstock has been reshaping its own position, recently sell sold off its East Texas Shelby Trough, assets to focus on its Louisiana core. Can click on that to see where that's at now. So nearly fifteen billion dollars in m and a in the last two years is visible right here. And the fragmentation below the top tiers tells us that the consolidation is probably not finished. So what I hope you take away is the ranking staff doesn't have to be just a leaderboard. It's a fast way to answer competitive questions. Who's growing? Who's pulling back? Which formations carry the most product weight? Sorry. Most production weight, and how operators stack up on a normalized efficiency basis, and what the geographic concentration of a play looks like. And everything updates dynamically with your map filters. So if you wanna scope this to a specific county, draw a polygon, the charts will update instantly. I'm happy to take any questions and show you other parts of the platform or talk through how this applies to your work. So feel free to ask question.
Share:
Related Resources
Live Webinar + Q&A Session What’s Upton? Growth outside Midland County In this on-demand webinar, Ben …
Live Webinar + Q&A Session What Can Your Acreage Position Tell You About Your Assets? In …
Live Webinar + Q&A Session Meeting the Moment: Marcellus and Haynesville Inventory Amid Rising Gas Demand …