Energy Leaders’ Stories Podcast

Griffin Investments: A Model for Generational Asset Building

Learn how Griffin Investments uses high-quality data and PDP underwriting to build a diversified, long-term mineral portfolio across US basins.

Podcast Description

The Griffin family’s business legacy in Oklahoma spans 115 years, with the investment arm, Griffin Investments, founded in 2013 to pool free cash flow from their media businesses (radio, television, and digital outdoor billboards).

Core Investment Philosophy and Success Factors:

  • Long-Term and Conservative: Their strategy is long-term buy and hold to build an asset base for future generations, focusing on real assets like minerals. They aim for conservative long-term capital appreciation, viewing yield as less important due to free cash flow from their media company.
  • Strategic Diversification: They are basin agnostic across the Lower 48 (Permian, Haynesville, Eagle Ford, Borken), but their portfolio is intentionally diversified by basins, operators, and commodities (targeting a 50/50 mix of oil and gas) to mitigate risk and ride out different market cycles.
  • Data-Driven Approach: They prioritize using high-quality data and a model-driven approach over speculation or “Wild West” guesswork. This allows them to systematically underwrite deals.
  • Focus on Underwriting Confidence: They focus primarily on the Proved Developed Producing (PDP) side of the business. Using advanced data and AI (specifically Novi Labs), they gain confidence in their volume projections, which allows them to make tighter, more competitive bids and win more acquisitions.
  • Operational Integrity: They differentiate themselves in the bidding process by committing to a deal and following through to close, avoiding the practice of “stringing out a close” to potentially flip a package.

Key Takeaway for Success: A critical piece of advice offered by Griffin Investments for those entering the royalty space is that having high quality data is very important. They stress that in today’s sophisticated market, “if you don’t have access to the same data as everybody else, you’re not playing the same game”.

Energy Leaders’ Stories Podcast

Energy Leaders’ Stories is where the real conversations in energy investing happen. In each episode, we sit down with the people building portfolios, deploying capital, and making decisions that shape today’s energy landscape. From multi-generation family offices and mineral buyers to operators and innovators, we dive into the strategies and philosophies behind their success.

You’ll hear how leaders approach risk, diversification, deal sourcing, and valuation, and how they use data, modeling, and technology to stay competitive in a rapidly evolving market. These aren’t abstract theories or polished press quotes. These are real stories, real challenges, and real lessons learned directly from the field.

Whether you work in minerals, upstream operations, private equity, or energy analytics, this podcast gives you a front-row seat to how experienced investors think, adapt, and build long-term value.

Energy Leaders’ Stories is designed for professionals who want deeper insight, better context, and smarter conversations about the future of the energy industry.

 

Podcast Transcript

Griffin family has a business legacy in Oklahoma that goes back a hundred and fifteen years. The family decided the best thing to do with that free cash flow is pull that into a company called Griffin Investments.

A lot of talk about AI data centers consuming a lot of gas production.

I mean, are bullish when it comes to natural gas. We see the economic indicators that that’s a fuel of the future.

We’re not speculating. We’re not making bets. We’re building generational that’s well diversified. It feels like we’re taking a lot of the the guesswork or the wild west out of it and turning it more into a model driven approach. Having high quality is very important, especially in this market now where if you don’t have access the same data, as everybody else, you’re not playing the same game.

Well thanks everyone for joining. I’m John Ludwig. I’m the founder and president of Novi Labs. Those of you in the audience who’ve not heard of our company, we provide data and AI driven data sets that help companies make better investment decisions.

Today, I’m here with Steve Forrester and Taylor McIntyre at Griffin Investments. We’re going to talk about a little bit of the history of Griffin, a little bit of market trends, how you guys see the market. And then also we’ll get into a little bit about how you use Nobi to create value and add accretive value to your portfolio. Steve, maybe could you introduce yourself and then Taylor?

Yes, thank you John. Really looking forward to the conversation today. My name is Steve Forrester and I’m the President of Griffin Investments. I’ve been with the Griffin family for over thirty eight years, and I’ve seen a lot of changes and a lot of evolution, and I’m looking forward to discussing that with you today.

Awesome. And I’m Taylor McIntyre. I’m Director of Investments here at Griffin Investments. I’m the lead on the oil and gas investing. Let’s start from the beginning.

Thirty eight years is a long time.

How did Griffin Investments get started out of the parent company? What’s the history?

Well, the Griffin family has a business legacy in Oklahoma that goes back one hundred and fifteen years. They’ve been in food manufacturing, radio, television, and currently we’re the largest media company in the state of Oklahoma with radio television stations in both Oklahoma City and Tulsa, which includes two of the top ten CBS affiliates in the country, digital outdoor billboards and network in both markets, as well as a lot of digital products.

And so from that, over the years, we started generating a lot of free cash flow. And the free cash flow, the family decided the best thing to do with that free cash flow is pull that into a company called Griffin Investments. So in twenty thirteen, we founded Griffin Investments and laid out an investment policy statement along with asset allocation and very intentionally built up portfolio over the last thirteen years of assets.

Outstanding. I mean what was the opportunity you saw that made the royalty space look attractive relative to other investments?

Well the Griffin family had acquired minerals over their years in Oklahoma as well as I had some experience from running my family’s mineral portfolio.

And part of our investment policy statement focused on generational assets, real assets. We were looking for long term appreciation and value.

Because of both the family and my experience in this space, we felt like minerals would be a good asset class to focus on. We did a little bit of non op, but now we’ve gravitated on the Griffin Energy side to primarily minerals.

Interesting. What part of the origin story still influences the way you invest today? I mean when you when you look at opportunities to buy assets.

You know, would say that the Griffin family is very strategic in everything they approach and so this has been a very strategic approach to acquiring minerals. We use a model driven approach that allows us to fully analyze every opportunity and determine what the market is and make an acquisition based on those metrics.

And I mean, if you think about your investment philosophy, if you had to just sum it up in one sentence, what would be an appropriate sentence?

I would say conservative long term capital appreciation. Yields not that important because we have a lot of yield or free cash flow that comes off of the media company. We just want to build an asset base for the generations.

So do you typically, when you buy an asset, do you typically think of it, I’m going to hold this for a long time or trade it at some point in the future or both?

Yes, no John, you’re right. It’s long term buy and hold. We’re again, we’re trying to build an asset base that’ll be passed along for generations in the future And you know as well as I do, most people that own minerals say I’ll never sell my minerals and that’s true with the Griffin family. We’re buying minerals to hold on to them in perpetuity.

So since twenty thirteen it’s just built and built and built.

We just keep adding net mineral acres to our portfolio.

Thinking about the process to bid on a new asset that you’re interested in acquiring, when you guys put your bids in, mean obviously there’s a cash component everyone cares everyone cares about cash but what what are some other ways that you differentiate yourself as a buyer relative to other competitive buyers?

One of the focuses we have is we say what we’re going to do when we make a commitment to buy based on our underwriting. We follow through, We close on the deal. There’s a lot of people in this industry that will string out a close until they can shop and potentially flip a mineral package. That’s not our MO. We commit and we follow through and close.

Taylor, you want to add to that?

Yeah, I’d add to that. So first and foremost, once again, like Steve said, we’re very conservative. So we focus on the PDP side, wells in progress side, the permit side. We’re not primarily buying white space hoping value hits.

So with that being said, we’re doing a lot of professional underwriting of the volumes using price decks to come up with the present value of that cash stream. And so when we’re underwriting software such as Novi is very helpful or useful in the sense that we have full confidence in the numbers and the projections that we’re going after when we’re underwriting. So we always say and Steve can expound on this too but we always say we have two main risks in the way we buy minerals. We have the underwriting volume risk and the price at risk or the commodity price.

We can’t control the commodity price, but we can do the best we can to control the volume underwriting.

Anything we can use, which NOVI is in this bucket, that allows us to aggressively underwrite our volumes to as close to actuals as possible is an edge for us.

So we can come into the bid process and not have to throw extra discounts on our bid just because we’re not sure what’s going to happen. So the more confidence we can have in the accuracy of our data, the more confidence we are in our bid, which then hopefully allows us to win more bids and end up with more acres, more wellbores through that process.

We never shy away from providing the capital to buy the best data available. The better we can underwrite the minerals, the less risk we’re taking going forward.

Yeah and I assume a lot of that really is based on what the wells produce in the future, like after you own them. Right.

Compared to the way we underwrote them when we acquired them exactly.

You’d like to be higher you know of course but where you thought would be great I would assume. So I’m curious as you think about all these opportunities to buy minerals, any particular focus oil versus gas, certain states more attractive than others from your perspective?

You know we’re really basin agnostic.

We’re okay acquiring minerals as long as they’re top basins in the lower forty eight.

But from Bakken all the way down to Eagle Ford, Haynesville, Permian, I mean, we buy in those basins. When it comes to oil and gas, well, overall our portfolio, we want it to be diversified. So we do try to diversify by operators, by basin, and by oil and gas. I mean, our target’s in the neighborhood of fiftyfifty. It’s never exact, but that way we have the ability to ride out markets because oil and gas do seem or tend to react differently to economic pressures or upside.

Yeah, so just tag along that.

Once again, we’re conservative and we like the diversity of the basins, the oil and gas mix, the life of the well. So whether it’s a long tail mature PDP well, or it’s a brand new well, or it’s just a permanent process, we like a mix of all that as well. And once again, so we have the diversity across basins, across commodities to the limit of risk ultimately.

Yeah, so there’s a, in the market, a lot of talk about AI data centers consuming a lot of gas production and we certainly see construction, commencing.

We certainly see larger AI companies making long term commitments to buy the power, if it can be generated. And then there’s LNG terminals, another, you know, potential future impact. Did either of those things, those big macro things going on change the way you think about the mix, like oil versus gas? Would you consider what maybe gas weighted would be good if these trends continue, demand goes up, therefore the price goes up? Does that weigh into your thinking at all or you’re underwriting purely based on the curve?

We’re underwriting primarily based on the curve. The upside, I mean, we are bullish when it comes to natural gas. We see the economic indicators that that’s a fuel of the future that will continue to rise in price. So we like our fiftyfifty balance. We don’t want to get out in front of our skis and put all our money in something we’re anticipating and it doesn’t happen. Diversification is so important for our portfolio.

We still get really excited when we hear about the power plants and the AI and the gas production because we we own a lot in the Haynesville, so it is exciting. But to Steve’s point, we want to keep it fifty fifty because we’re not we’re not speculating, we’re not making bets. We’re building generational asset that’s well diversified.

Yeah, I could see you know there are certainly lots of people you know betting on macro trends. Mean I recently saw you know Citadel which is I typically think of them as a hedge fund and they just bought an oil asset or excuse me a gas asset in in the Haynesville which I thought was unusual. That’s kind of what prompted the question. Mean they’re obviously making a macro bet but I sort you know as traders it’s kind of what they do. Sure they’re speculating. I don’t think generational you know wealth and continued cash returns is probably the biggest consideration you know for guys like that. Well considering a little bit more on you know kind of the market trends, when you when you guys think about yourselves versus other royalty buyers out there, you talk a little bit about biggest biggest misconception about royalty and non op investing now that people out there that don’t do it every day like you guys do would have.

So I’d say the market in general over the last ten years and then even the last five years and every year thereafter is getting more and more sophisticated every year. There’s more and more big players coming in with the nature of the resource plays with data that’s available. It’s a lot less of a wildcatting bet as opposed to systematically underwriting deals and systematically building portfolio.

And so that’s what we’ve seen on our end and that’s what we’ve been doing is be able to kind of, you know, if you’re in a thousand wellbores, yeah, might not underwrite every single one correctly, but on the whole, you’ll probably get it pretty close to right. And so that’s what we’re seeing and that’s where the data sources really matter. And I feel like it’s becoming if you don’t have access to same data, you’re you’re not playing the same game. And us on the side, the conservative side, once again, we’re not speculating, we’re not wildcatting, we’re not hitting white space. It can really be a differentiator of how many of the bids you make deals on, how many you can end up winning and getting those assets.

Yeah, and I don’t want to overlook the fact that we’re buying PDPs based on a low two digit net present value of future cash flows, but we’re also looking at future technology and recompletes and additional infill wells that will drive our IRRs in the future. And so the more we understand about that potential, the more valuable it is to us for the long term generational aspect of the asset.

Yeah, that makes sense. I mean, along those same lines, when you are looking at making an investment, let’s just say make it simple, there’s a hundred wells and let’s say the average age of the well is one year versus another hundred wells and the average age of the well is three years And let’s just say all other things are the same. Is it more attractive to you to have less weighting towards younger wells, which you know means more, they’re younger, they have more production, especially horizontal, they’re older, maybe a little bit more durable. Is there, do think of it differently if you were to view two assets that were otherwise equal relative to the young well versus old well mix?

I would think of it in terms of our portfolio, where our portfolio is currently constructed.

If it’s one hundred percent young wells, we would probably want that older well mix and then vice versa. But once again, I think when we’re looking at the data, it’s where are those wells? What’s the quality of the rock? Who’s the operator?

What’s the quality of the data that we’re getting on those wells? How hot is that basin right now? Are are we gonna have to pay for something extra in one that we’re not going to in the other? All those things factor in.

And then once again, if we’re looking at this as a long term view, yeah, today, there might be one package that’s more attractive than the other based on the current cash flow numbers, but the other package might have a lot more upside available over a ten year period. That’s actually a more attractive package. So there’s all those things we’re looking at when we’re going through this and NOVI definitely helps us to be able to analyze those and think through those and help get us to the decision we’re looking for.

If we’re looking at flush production, there’s obviously more risk And so the better the data is, the more comfortable we get with underwriting flush production. If you’re into long tail production, you’re taking some risk off the table, but you’re also taking some upside off the table. So data is so important to us.

When you look at a portfolio, do you also consider what the likely, like if there’s permits or work in progress wells, how much do you think about who the operator is in terms of that production getting delivered?

Yeah. Mean, think it’s a big deal. We all know not all operators are created equal. Not all rocks are created equal.

It’s just something you need to be aware of, right? This operator maybe fracs their wells a different way and their wells can look stronger. This operator, maybe they don’t frac in the same way and they’re more steady. And this is just when we’re talking about this kind of cash flow and bringing that back to present value, all those matter when that cash shows up.

So that’s how we look at it more in the sense of not this one or another, but what are the unique attributes of those operators.

And how are the operators capitalized?

The better their balance sheet, the more likelihood is that they’re going to be able to drill additional wells and develop that acreage underneath those minerals. So not looking necessarily at permits, but just five, ten, fifteen years down the road because these are generational assets for our portfolio. So as long as we have strong operators on good rock, you know, just repeating what Taylor said, in the right parts, in the right basins, the best basins, we feel like the asset base that we’re building will have cash flow for generations to come.

Think, you know, I’ve heard heard some very smart people say this and read about it and I think geology even supports it, but current technology only extracts fifteen to twenty percent of the hydrocarbons currently in the ground.

Well, we all know future technology will most likely extract another fifteen or twenty percent and as the mineral owner we’ll be there to extract that. So the data is real important for us to analyze that future potential of the rock in the areas that we’re buying minerals.

And it seems like the basins, if you take more mature basin like the Eagle Ford or the Williston, you’re seeing less activity of course. Those basins are heavily consolidated. I mean Crescent has been very active consolidating the Eagle Ford. Devon has been a consolidator in the Eagle Ford.

Devon has been a consolidator in the Williston. They’re right next door, to the studio here. So I guess I’m wondering, as you look at a package and you look at who’s who the operator is or who owns it, you think about, well that you know if that gets acquired it could be very different. Know if Devon acquires Grace and Mill it could be very different.

Crescent acquires, Ridgemar or Silverbow, Suddenly it could look really different. Do you think about that as or does that factor in at all into your calculation? Or do you think good rocks, good rocks, somebody’s going to drill it eventually and we’re in for the long haul anyways?

In our underwriting, we would most likely increase the discounted net present value of the future cash flows if it’s a smaller operator. But yes, we recognize the fact that that smaller operator could be acquired and consolidated with a larger operator in the future if it’s under the right rock in the right basin.

Crescent, recently announced an acquisition of Vital and in the actual announcement they said we’re going to cut the RICs from this number to this number and I think maybe they’re trying to figure out what’s under their feet and all that’s logical, but that can make a big difference to if you’re the mineral owner and suddenly they do a big slowdown. But if you guys are not underwriting super far into the future, that might be okay.

Right. And eventually it gets drilled.

Yeah. And then we’ve experienced that in our portfolio where we’ll we’ll say a smaller operator own the asset when we bought out the PDP wells. It got acquired by a larger operator who came in and drilled more additional wells. And then now that’s then since been acquired by an even larger operator, and they have rigs in the area and and frac crews in the area.

And and we don’t know this, but we’re thinking maybe they’re gonna come back and refrac the old wells. So I think it just goes back to, you know, the best areas under the best operators. And then two, maybe that means these particular wells may not be with that operator today, but the operator has a big position adjacent to it. And so that’s into the thought process as well.

Yeah. And let’s not overlook the fact from a macro perspective that Wall Street and the capital markets are putting pressure on these operators to operate within free cash flow. Well, does that mean? At least from our perspective, that means they’re more likely to drill additional wells where they’re familiar with what kind of volumes they’re going to extract, as opposed to exploring. Now, those companies have to balance because they have to have future prospects, so they need to balance, or through acquisition and consolidation, they may acquire additional drilling sites. We feel very comfortable as a middle owner buying on a value of the PDP wells, that all that upside is not part of our underwriting so it’s upside for us.

Last question on the consolidation topic just because there’s so much of it going on it’s kind of hard to avoid but I’m always curious how this affects how how an investor, royalty investor thinks. Actually you don’t control the rigs or the drill bit, or the completions but you’re hoping that somebody else will do what they’ve done in the past, right? So you look at something like the Midland that’s kind of there’s really like five companies left that own like eighty percent of the inventory, right? And there’s, you know, there’s certainly private equity backed companies, small companies, those big companies buy something big, they may sell a little piece, but something like the Delaware is still much more fragmented.

Does that change your appetite in a basin that’s that’s maybe a little bit more fragmented and gonna be subject to consolidation versus one that’s kind of already been consolidated?

I think if you look at it on a longer term scale and we know the quality of the rock is there, I don’t know if it’s important so much what’s happening today or tomorrow or next year. Just as we want to have these legacy long term generational assets and if in both those places, both high quality assets. So if we can own whatever we can own there, think that’s a plus.

And we tend to focus our acquisitions on portfolios that are masked by aggregators. So we’re dealing with those aggregators you’re talking about, and we’re buying from them. And that’s why it is a very intentional model driven approach. We aren’t going out and soliciting minerals from farmers and ranchers, nothing against them, but they aren’t as sophisticated in their understanding of the valuations. And so that’s where our focus is, on the aggregators.

Suppose they’re trying to generate their own family wealth long term.

Sure, and they have long memories.

They may have been offered big number of years ago and the market shifts and they don’t want to shift. But aggregators know when the market moves that the value of their minerals go up and down as the market moves.

You know if you kind of look at the royalty space in general, there’s been a few relatively high profile publicly traded royalty companies. So a good example is CTO who recently sold their assets to Viper. How how does that affect the way you guys view if you’re looking at a package, and you know that they’re bidding and they have access to public company capital, public company stock, does that affect at all your your position on the likelihood of acquiring the asset? Do you think it changes anything?

It changes in the sense that there’s a certain deal size we stay away from Yeah. Because we can’t compete with those guys. They obviously have more resources, more technical expertise than we do. So we stay we live in a deal size.

It’s kind of, I wouldn’t say under the radar of them. It’s just it’s it’s not big enough for them. Yeah. Sizable to us, sizable in in the mineral world, but not not to their scale.

And there’s less competition in that space. So it’s a better buyer’s market. And larger you get, the more you have to compete with public money and private equity. So we found our niche.

Yeah, well you know public companies have different requirements, right? You guys are generating long term wealth, they are not. It’s the next quarter, know the next year maybe that they’re thinking about, So they kind of have to feed the monkey, if you will, right. They have to buy assets that are big enough to be material. So it’s almost like it seems like Griffin operates above the I’m calling individual landowners and ranchers and farmers and stuff above that market, but below the threshold of being material for a public aggregator.

I’m curious, Novi recently wrote a piece on what we call the three eras. So the three eras our view were early shale, you know, before we hit price shock number one in twenty sixteen. And then there was a twenty sixteen to twenty twenty period where returns were not great. They were kind of mediocre, at least from the operator point of view, which, of course, influences how much how their investors think of them. And then there’s been the post COVID era, twenty twenty forward, where it seems like there’s been a return to free cash generation. Is that beneficial for you guys as an investor, just the general mode of operation of these companies today where they’re focused on returning cash to shareholders, which ultimately results in more profitable wells?

I’ll go back to what I said earlier in terms of if they have to operate within free cash flow, then there’s a focus on development as opposed to exploration and moving outside of the current known geology. And so that is beneficial from a mineral owner standpoint and royalty standpoint. I think long term, you want exploration and you want new areas to be developed. And we’d be buying those on PDP as well and benefit from that future drilling.

I’d say it’s filtered down for sure. We experienced a major shift in COVID to where we feel like pre COVID. And I think it kind of goes along with the operators, but it’s a little bit different. But we had to pay for upside in the minerals.

You couldn’t buy just on PDP or we couldn’t buy on PDP. We had to pay for that upside. And then that upside may or may not materialize. Post COVID, kind of the same thing.

It it went to this, you know, focus on free cash flow. The incentives got or the incentives changed, and we’re able to buy on PDP, just basically discounted cash flow as how we’ve been able to purchase since then. Granted, we’ve been targeted in what we’re looking for and not to say that other other modes don’t exist anymore, but that’s what we’ve been able to focus on and we’ve really been able to capitalize on on that shift shift in the market. Feel like it was a major shift that we felt and we were able to buy this way, which really suits our style of investing, the conservative long term model.

Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.

One other kind of market question for you guys.

As you look at, I know you’re willing to look at any basin and you’re interested in creating differentiation in your portfolio, have you seen the bid ask spread to be the same as it was a year ago in the Permian? A little bit little bit worse, a little bit better? Obviously, a lot of people competing there.

I’m just sort of curious if you’ve seen any shift in that basin.

The Permian’s tough, but we all know that’s that’s probably the most competitive market there is.

And you do have to pay for upside there, but rightfully so because it’s materializing time and time again. So I would say I’m not sure if the bid ask spread has tightened or worsened other than the market itself has over time become more sophisticated. Under the market over time understands what those PDP wells are worth. The market understands what those upside wells are worth, what the PUDs are worth.

And I guess with consolidation, you could almost put your own timing mechanism on when those PUDs are gonna be drilled. And so I would say, well, I’d say if anything, the bid ask spread might be tighter just because all the market participants understand where the value is and how to calculate that value. And it just comes down to, okay, well, what kind of time are you putting those PUDs or what price look are you using? What EURs are you using?

Which is all data driven, which goes back and speaks to the sophistication of the market.

Kind of a related question.

Last one I’ll ask about consolidation, I promise. It’s just an interesting topic right now, particularly in the Permian. Do you think companies like Diamondback, you know, rolling Viper back up underneath Diamondback, you know, Viper being a major buyer, obviously that changes the returns pretty dramatically. Like they’re going to think of returns inclusive of the royalty portion of return, which, of course, is going to affect their behavior. I’m kind of wondering, do you guys see companies like that that are major operators but also operate large royalty portfolios? Are those things a little bit less attractive to you guys just because they’re going be able to pay more just by paying more because they’re because of this sort of roll up effect it’s going to have on their on the overall company?

Yeah. I wouldn’t say they’re less attractive. It’s just that it’s harder to compete. Yeah. It’s really hard to compete with the operator of the wells when you’re bidding on the minerals. But with that being said too, the scale that they live at, there are still still opportunities to be had at a lower scale, just not at their scale.

So similar to kind of the the royalty aggregators, same kind of story. Right? Right. For it to be material to them, it’s got to be above a certain threshold. So you guys operate regardless of who who who’s bidding, you operate at a different scale.

Correct.

Yeah. One more kind of macro question. Do you see any kind of future macro trends that are going to change things materially for a royalty buyer in the future? We talked a little bit about our data centers or coming online. Is there anything else that you guys think about as a macro trend that could potentially change things?

And I think one is the improvement of data that’s available to analyze and underwrite acquisitions. The sophistication of the industry, think that’s one reason why you see a Viper being integrated into Diamondback is because it’s no longer an afterthought when it comes to the royalty that comes with the minerals. That’s such a valuable aspect. And from a macro standpoint, it’s going to be whoever has the best data can underwrite the best and hit their numbers. So I don’t know, there’s a lot of things in play here, but it’s becoming more of a sophisticated market, fair to say?

Yeah, think, I mean, we’re obviously in the business of predicting future production of wells. That’s what NOVA does. But we also provide all the historical data in service to that. And we’ve certainly seen confidence improve in the models that we’re building.

I mean, know what statistical confidence is, right? More data that is available, the more confidence that you can have. So maybe that combined with changing operator behaviors since the COVID period that we talked about earlier, those two things combined maybe serve to de risk things a little bit, you know, for investors like you guys. Would that be a fair statement?

I’d say yes. Yeah, I agree.

You mentioned earlier, Steve, it started in twenty thirteen. How different is it now as you guys think about doing an evaluation versus what you had to work with, you know, back then from a data perspective?

I’d say it’s light years different. I mean, back in twenty thirteen, you’re looking at a deal and you’re saying, hey, well, I know that this just traded over here for X. And so if I can get it for Y, I think we’ve got a good deal. That’s that feels like maybe a little bit more sophisticated than that, but that feels like about right.

And whereas today, we’re running the whole PDP value. Are there new wells? Who’s the operator? What are the EURs of the well?

What price deck are we using? All these inputs to make, one, a much better decision and and two, a high quality decision. Whereas before, it feels like we’re taking a lot of the the guesswork or the Wild West out of it and turning it more into a model driven approach where we can scale that approach and we can look at hundreds of deals over and over again with the same analytics so we can do our best to compare apples to apples and and make the best investment decisions.

Would it be a fair statement to say that you you would expect as more and more data accumulates, companies like NOVI are going be able to provide you with even things that even narrow the risk band a little bit more.

Absolutely.

Yeah, we think about it the same way ourselves, right? Because we have the proof, we have the receipts. You know, it’s certainly easier to invest now than it was in twenty thirteen. When you think about, and maybe Taylor, it’s a question for you, because you probably do this every day. A deal comes across your desk, just use our one hundred example, talk us through kind of like how you would process that.

Like what would you do from the moment it comes in to the moment you say, okay, I want more information or pass?

Sure. So once again, we’ll start with we’re buying PDP, wells in progress permits. So with that being said, what we’re gonna wanna see from the seller is we’re gonna have an API list and a decimal list with those APIs. So that way we can dump it into Novi, and we can pull as well as back out.

Another thing we’ll look for is our revenue statements. So we have actual revenue statements, and as we run our forecasts, we’re comparing the actual revenues, historical actual revenues to what we’re projecting to make sure we’re online. That’s really what we need from the seller. And we put that into our models and we run the forecast out several different ways.

We put our price x on it, we kind of do a sensitivity analysis on it. And we come back and decide what kind of I say we decide, we have our range of our discount rates that we’re willing to pay for those that mix of assets, and we come back and make our offer. Usually, that’s a pretty tight offer as far as is what our final number is. And and what we’ll do then is with the seller.

Usually the sellers we’re working with, they’ve done something similar as well. So it’s just a matter of, okay, what what variables are we both using and what can we agree upon and what do we not agree upon? And, that usually gets us to a deal. But with that process, we can go through a lot of deals really quickly by having these data sources and having the confidence in data.

And I think we haven’t touched on it quite yet, but one of the big benefits we like with NOVI is we all know wells that have less than six months of production are really tough to forecast. And how do you have the confidence? Is this going to be a barn burner or is this going to be a dud? We don’t know.

But with our NOVI data, what we’ve seen is we have a higher level of confidence with the data it’s spitting out or the forecast it’s it’s projecting than we have with with other things we’ve looked at. And so what that means is when we’re we’re dealing with the seller, we can be as aggressive as we can, within the range of what is reasonable opposed to, you know, we’re so underbid that we’re so far off in the bid ask thread we can’t get a deal done or we’re overshooting it to where we made a bad investment.

So those are the things that really help when we’re analyzing our data and going through our process of analyzing the deal.

Yeah, and the only thing I would add to that is, yes, you’re fully analyzing the existing APIs in the sections we’re buying, but you’re also looking at, or we’re also looking at all the wells that are adjacent in a nine section area or larger, all those EURs come into play and as part of the formula for underwriting the acquisition. Right, right.

And two, I’d say, when you’re looking at large complex deal, you know, eighty to ninety percent of the data is for the Wells is going be pretty easy and pretty simple. It’s that last ten percent is what gets you the deal done or not. And how how can you analyze and process that last ten percent?

And, that’s where confidence in your data, having high quality data, and being able to have confidence in making bids on that data comes into play for us.

Yeah, that makes sense. So I guess when you you chose to work with with Novi, obviously, you had a data source prior. What were some of the things that led you to want to make a different go in a different direction?

Yeah. And so I guess we’ll hit on to it’s it’s the confidence in the data.

And and maybe you can speak to the actual data sources and how the technicalities and how it all works. But but the confidence in the data, the ease of the use, and the ability to quickly analyze our packages and and spit out or or turn around and answer out the door. Those were key for us because we run a lean team. We like having a lean lean team and, being able to take a large volume of deals and high grade those deals and, build out a portfolio is is key to us. And and Novi definitely has helped speed that process up, especially on that last ten percent. Those are the ones that can take add days to your analysis. And if we can shorten that time frame, that helps us just get more deals through the door.

So in short, having confidence in the NOVY PDP forecast is something that allows you to evaluate a materially larger number of deals.

Correct, yes. Because then with that confidence when we see the number that comes out, it’s close to what we kind of expected that number to be, it gives us, you know, we can move forward with that opposed to something looks off here and we have to dig through and find out what that is.

So I know in the past we’ve talked about, Taylor, we’ve talked about you observing situations where, looking at a well’s forecast and it’s not declining properly and then you have to double click on that and go way into it to figure out, well, why is that? Because you can’t have a two million barrel EUR, That doesn’t seem likely. Are you finding you see less of those situations in your use of the NOVY production data and NOVY forecasts? Yes.

And this goes back to, let’s say, our wells that are less than six months old. With that, you know, with software and algorithms and the formulas, there’s limitations there. And it can it can throw out a two million barrel EUR or a twenty thousand barrel EUR, and we don’t know both of those are wrong. But what I’ve experienced with the NOVI data is that that range is much tighter, where we can look at it and say, Okay, yeah, that passes the eye test.

And if we need to dig in, we can dig in and we can find those those variables. But most of the time, it comes back right really kind of where we expect it to be or or a number we feel comfortable with or a number that was like, yeah, we like this. Maybe it tweaks up or down a little bit, but it’s generally spot on. And that’s been a huge time saver for us.

And once again, it’s it’s the confidence and efficiency that builds on that. And then the more more opportunities we run through that model, and the more we see that, obviously, the more confidence we get. And that’s been really helpful for us.

So in summary, it’s all about speed and accuracy, and Novi enhances both of them. It allows us to evaluate more deals and we’re more accurate when we evaluate more deals. So it’s a win win.

We originally developed our AI PDP forecast technology with a large operator in the Midland. And their goal was simple. I would like to see eighty five to ninety percent of my PDP forecast go all the way through to reserves, which means it’s got to pass finance, which means it’s got to be good enough to support quarterly investor reporting, right, which is kind of a big deal.

Pioneer was drilling enough wells at that time where thirty percent of their production volume in a given quarter was wedge, meaning from wells that were just coming online. Hence the extreme focus that we put on the young well performance for these models. And then the other big thing, and this is kind of something that took us more than a year to get right, is tuning the forecast such that we miss as small as possible. Putting guardrails on it that recognize, you know, dips in production volume that aren’t likely to stay as a dip, they’re gonna it’s gonna return back on curve, you know, and spikes.

So we had, I remember this like it was yesterday, we had lots of wells, probably fifteen percent of wells in any given run we were doing, and there were thousands of wells. When we were building this technology, about fifteen percent of them were spikes or drops, guardrailing things such that we jerk the forecast too far up or too far down based upon these short term changes in volume. Short term changes in volume could just be a reporting anomaly. It could be especially if you’re dealing with data that ultimately was sourced from the state.

There could have been a bad well test or any number of things that that changed dramatically. But that was probably the hardest part, was getting the last mile, you know, the last fifteen percent. And I think it was because of our focus on getting the short term volume reporting as correct or accurate as it could be and avoiding big misses, in the in the longer running wells, you know, from spikes and dips that are normal in production. I mean, remember a period of time that I call snow vid, which is which is a week in February in Austin where we had like an ice storm, you know, for like a whole, you know, for like a whole week and and a lot of production got shut in.

You know, wells froze up, you know, caused long term ripple effects on gas supply, which then caused ripple effects on my heat doesn’t work in my house and my lights don’t turn on anymore.

But I remember the impact that that had. Like, there was a bulk downshift in production of wells that was really an anomaly based on weather that happened and then the wells all returned to curve. So that was actually right at the end of us building this technology and we’re like, uh-oh, we may have an event like this that shuts off West Texas, basically.

Obviously it has a huge impact on production, but you wouldn’t want, as a royalty investor, to assume that production is going to stay at that low level, right? It’s going to when the wells come back on, they’re probably going to return back relatively close to the curve. So making it durable for those types of things and not letting it be run led astray. I mean, in the AI world, there’s always lots of talk about hallucinations.

And in our space, that’s a hallucination. Hallucinating. The production is going to be way higher or way lower. Last question relating to Tanovee.

As you were evaluating us as a partner, we’ve talked about production data, forecasts, anything else that stood out as a partner, anything else you were looking for from a service provider?

Yeah, so I mean, we’ve talked and hit on the confidence in the data, the ability for the efficiency and scale in the sense of being able to run through those and and analyze more opportunities.

And another piece too that we haven’t really touched on yet as the Novi intelligence is the I’ll call it the PUD module. So this has been great for us in the sense that it’s built out all the sticks with the EURs, the different landing zones. And so we can quickly, and once again, this goes back to the scale and the efficiency, we can quickly look to see what kind of publications are left. And then we can apply those in in our cash flow model to see how if we need to get any value or just even though it’s there. So if we’re looking at two deals that on the surface look the same, but one deal has twice as many publications remaining, but we can buy them on the same discount rate, maybe this is the one we go for. So once again, it’s a way to hydrate our deal flow and to eventually or hopefully acquire better and higher quality assets.

So even though you may not be giving underwriting credit to the the non WIP and non permanent locations, knowing that there’s a lot of them affects the way that you think about the upside. Even if it’s not quantified in your model driven approach, Steve said earlier. One hundred percent.

Yeah. And just one quick thing that kind of separates Novi from other software offerings and that is so often it’s approached as a transactional relationship as opposed to a personal relationship. And maybe I’m stretching it with personal, but here we are sitting here doing a video with you as one of your clients and your vendor. And that’s very much a personal relationship as opposed to just a vendor client relationship.

So the personalized service is well appreciated by us.

Tag along on that too is the support that comes along with it. When there’s been issues or I want issues isn’t the right word but when I’ve had questions or need to know how to work a certain module or how to do this or that, I’ve gotten one, a very quick response and two, a very thorough response every single time. And so I think that speaks to the personal relationship. It’s not a transaction. It’s very obvious you guys do not treat these as transactions and it’s noticeable in the client service side.

Yeah, that’s much appreciated. We try really hard in that space and I think similar to the oil and gas space, sort of are differentiated I think by people wanting to have a different experience working with their vendor. So instead of a price increase every year and that’s the only time you ever talk to somebody from the company and if you file a support ticket, there’s a long time. We’re trying to differentiate on our service of course and we’re smaller than our competitors, but I try to make sure the company continues to act as we did when we were five people in a garage.

We’re forty people now, we’re much bigger, but still a lot smaller than our larger data subscription type companies. So it matters a lot to us and we think of our success as a company, we measure by revenue just like you guys would measure your performance with return on your portfolio but there’s also other things that differentiate you as well. Know, are you easy to deal with commercially? Know, space has been bought up.

I mean, biggest competitor just got bought by another private equity firm, right?

Private equity firms have playbooks, and they’ve been owned by four different ones that I can remember, each time focus changes. Know, I think we’ve been or we’ve tried to be at least consistent with how we’ve dealt with customers and the level we put into support regardless of how much somebody’s paying. We think of it like every customer one is a customer one, hopefully for a long time. Yeah, same as your view on the royalty space and we look at it, you know, we do a good transaction just like probably the same with you guys, a good transaction with a customer, then they’re going to think of us first, when they go to a different company or you know whatever. So those relationships matter, every one of them matters for us. So that’s just I think something we try to do a little differently.

Well your culture is definitely reflected in the way you operate. See it. So you’re being successful in that objective.

Thank you. That’s great. Last thing, one future question and then we’ll call it a wrap for today, guys. Do you have any advice for anyone looking to be successful in the royalty space? Maybe three things you guys have done that has led to you getting where you are today from starting twenty thirteen.

First thing I’d say is don’t bid on anything. Just let us take care of it and leave the market to us.

Would you like to say anything?

Yeah, well, think I mean, I think paying for your data is important. Having high quality is very important, especially in this market now where where it’s becoming more and more sophisticated. And if you don’t have access to same data as everybody else, you’re not you’re not playing the same game. And I think that’s a huge piece. And I think that’s my biggest takeaway is, and as we go into this kind of next phase of technology, I think that’s going be more and more so.

Well, I think we’ll call it a wrap for today, guys.

Thank you very much for your time and sharing your beautiful studio here, to have this discussion today and, look forward to seeing the results.

Awesome, you, John. Appreciate it.

Share:

Related Resources

Top of the Barrel Podcast Can Exxon’s Permian Reach 2.5 Million BOE/D? Can Exxon deliver on …

Podcast Innovative Data-Driven Approaches That Are Shaping the Future of Energy Supply and Exploration In this …

Top of the Barrel Podcast Inside 2026 Producer Hedging: What Oil and Gas Operators Are Positioning …

Meet Novi Labs' knowledgeable experts.
Invite to Speak

Please provide us some information about your event, and we will get back to you as soon as we can

Expert form

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
News, trends and data for the US upstream industry
Receive latest updates on the energy industry into your inbox.

Sign up today for free and get a weekly email with News and insights on important developments in the major tight oil & gas basins.

Subscribe form (popup)

"(Required)" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.